England Expresses Frustration Over Harshit Rana Replacing Shivam Dube
India secured a 15-run victory over England to clinch the T20I series, but the spotlight was firmly on a contentious decision involving the concussion substitution of Harshit Rana for Shivam Dube. While the replacement was approved by the match referee, it drew criticism from former England captains Alastair Cook and Michael Vaughan, who found the decision baffling.
The controversy arose in the final over of India’s innings when Shivam Dube, who had played a crucial knock of 53 runs, was struck on the helmet by a Jamie Overton bouncer off the penultimate delivery. After an on-field assessment, he was cleared to face the last ball. However, India was later allowed to bring in Harshit Rana as his concussion substitute— a move that allowed Rana to bowl during England’s chase, ultimately playing a decisive role in India’s win.
England’s Concern Over ‘Like-for-Like’ Replacement Rule
The main point of contention for England was the stark contrast between Dube and Rana as players. While Dube is a batting all-rounder who bowls occasionally, Rana is an out-and-out fast bowler, regularly clocking speeds close to 90 mph. Under ICC regulations, concussion substitutes must be “like-for-like”, and England believed this substitution did not adhere to the rule.
Former England captain Alastair Cook openly criticized the decision on TNT Sports, saying:
“Replacing a big-hitting batting all-rounder, who has bowled just one over in the IPL this year, with a specialist fast bowler who can’t bat makes no sense whatsoever.”
He further added, “It seems absolute madness that this was allowed. Credit to the lad on debut, but he shouldn’t have been playing. It gave India’s captain another brilliant option.”
Michael Vaughan echoed Cook’s frustration, taking to social media to voice his displeasure. He posted on X (formerly Twitter):
“How can an out-and-out bowler replace a batter who bowls part-time?!?!?!?!?! #INDvsENG”
Rana Shines on Debut, Seals India’s Victory
Despite the controversy, 23-year-old Harshit Rana made the most of his unexpected debut, delivering a match-winning performance with the ball. He dismissed Liam Livingstone, Jacob Bethell, and Jamie Overton, finishing with figures of 3-33. With England needing 25 runs from 12 balls, Rana was entrusted with the penultimate over, where he conceded just six runs and took the crucial wicket of Overton, effectively sealing India’s win.
While England remains frustrated with the decision, India’s use of the concussion substitute proved decisive, raising fresh debates about the interpretation of the ‘like-for-like’ rule in cricket.
