Day 3 of the fourth Border-Gavaskar Trophy Test at Melbourne saw a fiery on-air debate between Australian cricket legends Mark Waugh and Michael Hussey, following Rishabh Pant’s dismissal. The Indian wicketkeeper-batter’s ambitious ramp shot ended in a catch at third man, sparking criticism and contrasting opinions among the commentators.
Pant’s Aggression Ends in Disappointment
Resuming on Day 3, Pant, known for his attacking approach, was batting on 28 when he attempted a scoop off Scott Boland. The delivery, full and angled, got the better of him, leading to a top-edge that was comfortably caught in the deep. With India at 191/5 and chasing Australia’s first-innings total of 474, his dismissal compounded the visitors’ struggles.
Despite showing patience for 40-45 minutes, Pant’s decision to play a high-risk shot disappointed many, including Waugh, who called it “unacceptable.”
Heated Exchange Among Commentators
Speaking on Fox Cricket, Waugh expressed his disapproval of Pant’s shot selection. “That’s unacceptable. I know he’s an aggressive player, but you’ve got to read the game situation. With two fielders placed for that exact shot, the percentages are not in your favor unless you clear the ropes. It was too risky,” he said.
Waugh suggested a more measured approach, saying, “If you’re going to attack, run at the bowler and hit over mid-off. That’s a better option than this reckless attempt.”
However, Hussey defended Pant’s natural playing style. “It’s tough because that’s how he plays. If you try to change him too much, you risk confusing him. Yes, it was a poor shot, but you don’t want to take away his instinctive game,” Hussey argued.
Vaughan Joins the Debate
England legend Michael Vaughan also weighed in, siding with Hussey. “Rishabh Pant is a rare talent. He plays a unique style of cricket, and I believe he should have the freedom to continue playing that way,” Vaughan remarked.
Waugh, however, doubled down, emphasizing the need for smarter shot selection. “That’s not an excuse. As much as I appreciate aggression, there has to be a level of restraint and calculated risk,” he said.
Waugh’s Final Dig at Hussey
The heated discussion ended with a sharp exchange between Waugh and Hussey. When Hussey remarked that he wouldn’t want Pant to change his style, Waugh quipped, “That’s why you’re not the head coach, just the assistant.” The remark, referencing Hussey’s role as an assistant coach with England and in the IPL, drew laughter from the panel, including Vaughan.
India’s Late Fightback
While Pant’s dismissal was a setback, Nitish Kumar Reddy stepped up for India later in the day. Coming in at 191/6, he scored a maiden Test century, remaining unbeaten on 105*. Reddy’s efforts took India to 358/9 at stumps, reducing the deficit to 116 runs and keeping their hopes alive in the Test.
